ChatGPTと会話しました！（その２０）英検1級エッセイ問題「2017年度 第3回」
今回は依頼内容が通じていなかったので作り直してもらいました。ChatGPTは遊べます。
英語塾：Hello Chat! Here is an english test which was carried out in Japan. I would like you to make a sample answer for me. Please make your essay look being written by high school student in the USA. Also tell me how many words you used in your essay. Please make the both pros and cons essays. Thanks in advance.
:
- Write an essay on the given TOPIC.
- Give THREE reasons to support your answer.
- Structure: introduction, main body, and conclusion
- Suggested length: 200 240 words
- Write your essay in the space provided on Side B of your answer sheet.
- Any writing outside the space will not be graded.
- TOPIC : Should Japan rethink its relationship with the United States?
Title: Should Japan Rethink Its Relationship with the United States?
ChatGPT：In recent years, there has been growing debate in Japan about its relationship with the United States. As a high school student in the USA, I believe there are both pros and cons to consider in this matter.
On the one hand, there are several reasons why Japan should rethink its relationship with the United States. Firstly, Japan has been highly dependent on the United States for its security since World War II, relying on the U.S. military for protection. This has limited Japan’s ability to develop its own independent defense capabilities and assert its sovereignty in the region. Secondly, the economic relationship between Japan and the United States has been imbalanced, with Japan often facing trade barriers and tariffs imposed by the United States, which can hinder Japan’s economic growth. Lastly, Japan has sometimes felt overshadowed by the United States in international relations, with its own interests taking a backseat to those of the U.S.
On the other hand, there are also compelling reasons for Japan to maintain its close relationship with the United States. Firstly, the U.S. has been a key ally in ensuring Japan’s security and stability in the region, especially with the increasing threat of North Korea and China’s assertiveness in the East China Sea. Secondly, the economic ties between Japan and the United States have been mutually beneficial, with both countries benefiting from trade and investment with each other. Lastly, Japan has often relied on the United States for diplomatic support on the international stage, such as in addressing global challenges like climate change and terrorism.
In conclusion, while there are valid arguments on both sides, I believe that Japan should carefully consider the pros and cons of its relationship with the United States. It may be necessary for Japan to assert its own interests and sovereignty, but it should also acknowledge the benefits of its alliance with the United States in terms of security, economic cooperation, and diplomatic support. As a high school student in the USA, I believe that a balanced approach that takes into account the complex dynamics of the Japan-U.S. relationship is essential for Japan’s future. (245 words)
英語塾：Thank you so much but I should ask you in this way. Here is an english test which was carried out in Japan. I would like you to make a sample answer for me. Please make your essay look being written by high school student in the USA. Also tell me how many words you used in your essay. Please make two essays. One is from the pros standpoint and the other is from the cons standpoint. Thanks in advance.
:
- Write an essay on the given TOPIC.
- Give THREE reasons to support your answer.
- Structure: introduction, main body, and conclusion
- Suggested length: 200 240 words
- Write your essay in the space provided on Side B of your answer sheet.
- Any writing outside the space will not be graded.
- TOPIC : Should Japan rethink its relationship with the United States?
Essay 1 (Pros standpoint): Should Japan Rethink Its Relationship with the United States?
ChatGPT：As a high school student in the USA, I believe that Japan should rethink its relationship with the United States due to several compelling reasons.
Firstly, Japan has been heavily reliant on the United States for its security since World War II. The presence of U.S. military bases in Japan has been crucial in ensuring Japan’s defense against potential threats in the region, particularly with the growing tensions from North Korea and China. However, this reliance on the U.S. has limited Japan’s ability to develop its own independent defense capabilities and assert its sovereignty in the region. By reevaluating its relationship with the United States, Japan could potentially explore more autonomous defense strategies and strengthen its sovereignty.
Secondly, the economic relationship between Japan and the United States has been imbalanced. Japan has often faced trade barriers and tariffs imposed by the United States, which can hinder its economic growth. By reconsidering its relationship with the United States, Japan could potentially renegotiate trade agreements and seek fairer economic terms that benefit both countries. This could lead to a more mutually beneficial economic partnership.
Lastly, Japan has sometimes felt overshadowed by the United States in international relations. Its own interests and concerns have sometimes taken a backseat to those of the U.S. By reassessing its relationship with the United States, Japan could assert its own interests and have a more balanced approach in international relations, promoting its own diplomatic agenda and priorities.
In conclusion, Japan should carefully rethink its relationship with the United States to address issues related to security, economy, and international relations. By taking a more autonomous approach and considering its own interests, Japan can potentially strengthen its sovereignty, promote economic cooperation, and have a more balanced diplomatic stance on the global stage. (237 words)
Essay 2 (Cons standpoint): Should Japan Rethink Its Relationship with the United States?
As a high school student in the USA, I believe that Japan should not hastily reconsider its relationship with the United States, as there are compelling reasons to maintain the status quo.
Firstly, the U.S. has been a key ally in ensuring Japan’s security and stability in the region. The presence of U.S. military bases in Japan has deterred potential threats and provided a security umbrella for Japan, particularly in the face of North Korea’s nuclear provocations and China’s assertiveness in the East China Sea. By maintaining its relationship with the United States, Japan can continue to benefit from this security partnership and safeguard its national interests.
Secondly, the economic ties between Japan and the United States have been mutually beneficial. Both countries have enjoyed trade and investment benefits from their economic cooperation. The United States is one of Japan’s major trading partners, and any disruption in this relationship could have negative economic consequences for Japan. By maintaining its relationship with the United States, Japan can ensure continuity in economic cooperation and continue to benefit from the bilateral trade and investment opportunities.
Lastly, Japan has often relied on the United States for diplomatic support on the international stage. The United States has been an important ally for Japan in addressing global challenges such as climate change, terrorism, and regional conflicts. By maintaining its relationship with the United States, Japan can continue to leverage this diplomatic support and amplify its voice on the global stage.
In conclusion, Japan should carefully consider the benefits of its current relationship with the United States in terms of security, economy, and diplomatic support. While there may be concerns and challenges, maintaining a strong partnership with the United States can ensure Japan’s security, economic stability, and diplomatic influence in the international arena. (236 words)
